On International Women’s Day, PPF calls attention to attacks on women journalists; the safety of women journalists must be ensured

As the world observes International Women’s Day, Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF) calls attention to the attacks, harassment and abuse that women journalists in Pakistan face and urges the need for tackling such attacks on women in the media. The safety — both physical and mental — of women journalists must be ensured.

While the media as a whole in Pakistan faces numerous challenges including physical attacks, online harassment and threats of attack within a restrictive media landscape, the attacks on women journalists additionally take on a gendered nature focussed on character assassination and personal attacks on them.

During a series of political rallies in May 2022, journalists on the ground were subjected to acts of violence. In one such instance, woman journalist Samaa TV reporter ZamZam Saeed was injured after being attacked by Pakistan Tehreek Insaf (PTI) supporters in Karachi.

In a tragic accident, Channel 5 reporter Sadaf Naeem lost her life after being run over by a container PTI chairman and former prime minister Imran Khan was travelling in during his political party’s “Long March” in Punjab.

Naeem’s death was a tragic loss of life that highlights the need for safety training for the media. It should serve as a wake-up call for the media, political parties and authorities organizing such rallies about the necessary arrangements needed to ensure the safety of journalists on the field.

Along with physical attacks, women journalists have in particular come under attack online. Hateful messages, morphed images and vile messages about women journalists are often shared on social media platforms. Leading women journalists have on repeated occasions become the target of campaigns that are sometimes led or supported by political parties.

In August 2020, a group of Pakistani women journalists issued a statement highlighting the nature of the abuse they were experiencing. According to the joint statement, women were targeted for their viewpoints, particularly regarding the government’s handling of Covid-19, making it “incredibly difficult” for them to carry out their professional duties.

The joint statement noted that women journalists were called “peddlers of ‘fake news,’ ‘enemy of the people’ and accused of taking bribes (often termed ‘paid’ journalists or lifafas”).

Additionally, they said that their social media timelines were “barraged with gender-based slurs, threats of sexual and physical violence,” and attempts to hack their accounts.

PPF has observed that political rhetoric by senior political leaders also targets women journalists or makes excuses for the abuse they face. This is a dangerous precedent that can further lead to inciting attacks or abuse against these journalists.

On October 18, 2022, PTI chairman Khan stated that NewsOne anchorperson Gharidah Farooqi was opening herself up for attacks by entering male-dominated spaces. Khan referenced Farooqi and said: “Gharidah Farooqi enters the crowd and then complains of harassment”.

In a tweet, Farooqi shared that in response to a question regarding the trolling and attacks on journalists, Khan replied: “If Gharidah Farooqi shoves herself with men, then this will happen.”

Laws passed for the protection of women in the workplace and for the safety of journalists and media professionals must be implemented in order to ensure that a safe work environment for women in the media can be created. The lack of acknowledgement, seriousness and effort to counter such acts must also be changed with a concerted effort to document and condemn such attacks.

Both the Sindh Protection of Journalists and Other Media Practitioners Act, 2021 and the federal-level Protection of Journalists and Media Professionals Act, 2021 guarantee protection against harassment. The Sindh-level law goes a step further by differentiating between broader harassment and sexual harassment, which defines sexual harassment as defined in the Protection Against Harassment of Women at the Workplace Act, 2010. These laws should provide a legal avenue for protection against harassment within the workplace through effective implementation.

 

The post On International Women’s Day, PPF calls attention to attacks on women journalists; the safety of women journalists must be ensured first appeared on Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF).

Wikipedia ‘downgrade’

ATTEMPTS to police the internet by states, often by giving opaque justifications for the action, are never a good idea. It should be recalled that this nation was deprived of YouTube in 2012 for three years after a crude anti-Islam film was uploaded on the platform. The video-sharing giant has also been blocked briefly more recently to prevent livestreaming of PTI rallies. However, the latest global portal to fall foul of the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority is Wikipedia, the free, editable online encyclopaedia often used as a starting point by millions across the world for basic information. The PTA has slowed down access to the site in Pakistan apparently because it failed to “block/remove sacrilegious content”. The regulator says Wikipedia has neither responded to its requests, nor taken down the content in question. Furthermore, it has threatened to block Wikipedia across Pakistan in case of non-compliance.

The fact is that the internet is a very difficult place to police, while questions about citizens’ rights to information also arise if states start blocking entire web portals or apps. Unfortunately, some platforms are used to upload content that breaks local laws or is designed to inflame passions. The best course may be to ignore such random provocations, instead of giving them more prominence. However, if there is serious incitement to hatred or violence, action can be taken by working with the platforms to single out such content and isolate it. Shutting down entire portals should be avoided. The state needs to reconsider its threat to ban Wikipedia. Pakistan has much bigger things on its plate to worry about than a few provocative articles on Wikipedia. Moreover, blocking sites does not do much to encourage the growth of the digital economy in the country. Fair questions also arise about the arbitrariness of such decisions. Under the guise of blocking ‘offensive’ content, the state can easily silence critics, while preventing free access to information.

Source: Dawn 

(Editorial)

The post Wikipedia ‘downgrade’ first appeared on Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF).

Live screening of Pakistan’s UPR session

Islamabad: Member states of United Nations Human Rights Council recommended Pakistan to strengthen human rights intuitions, protect the rights of vulnerable groups, abolish capital punishment, sign the international convention on enforced disappearance and investigates all reports of intimidation and violence against journalists and human rights defenders.

The recommendations were made in the Pakistan’s Universal Periodic Review (UPR) by the 42nd session of UPR Working Group in the UN Human Rights Council held on Monday.

The session was live screened at an event organised jointly by National Commission for Human Rights (NCHR), Justice Project Pakistan (JPP) and Parliamentarians Commission for Human Rights (PCHR).

The live screening was held in the presence of prominent civil society activists, diplomats, journalists, students and government representatives. To maximise social media outreach of the session, the event also featured live tweeting with a hashtag #UPRPak besides providing a space for informal discussions among relevant stakeholders. A simultaneous screening event also took place in Lahore.

In addition to that, the participants also expressed their opinion through posters inscribed with emojis of smile and tied lips, and signs such as ‘Danger: High Voltage’ and ‘Just Do It’, etc. Participants displayed posters of ‘Danger: High Voltage’ and started hooting in response to comments from Indian delegate. The public interest in the process resulted in the hashtag #UPRPak trending on the twitter at the end of the session.

Chairperson of the NCHR, Rabiya Javeri Agha opened the live screening event with a keynote address. She briefed the participants about the country’s international human rights obligations and the value of the UPR review process for promotion and protection of human rights. “Struggling with the advancement of human rights in Pakistan is a bit like playing snakes and ladders because sometimes we take two steps forward and go one step back,” she said.

Her speech was followed by remarks from MNA Mehnaz Akbar Aziz. She said that Pakistan’s Parliament has a history of raising voice for vulnerable. “Pakistan is one of the four countries with the Parliamentary Caucus on Child Rights,” she added.

In a three and a half hours UPR session, Pakistan was given 30 minutes to explain progress it has made in realising human rights since the last review. The presentation was followed by 140 minutes of Human Rights Council member states making recommendations and asking questions. The sessions ended with another 40 minutes given to Pakistan for answering the questions and addressing issues raised during the session and making the final comments. All the recommendations from states would be presented to Pakistan one months after the session.

From Pakistan’s side, State Minister for Foreign Affairs Hina Rabanni Khar presented Pakistan’s case in her usual comprehensive and articulate manner, stating that human rights lie deep in the foundation of Pakistan and appreciating the UPR process. She was joined by Senator Walid Iqbal and Secretary Ministry of Human Rights Ali Raza Bhutta.

The Pakistani delegation briefed the member states about the legal and institutional measures taken by the Pakistani government for promotion and protection of human rights. State Minister said that Pakistani government and the Parliament is committed of safeguarding the human rights of the people of Pakistan. She said that Pakistan’s National Commission for Human Rights functions under Paris Principles of Independence and all human rights institutions in Pakistan are headed by women. She said that human rights management system has helped the government craft an evidence-based policy and implement treaty body reports.

Delegates from different countries commended Pakistan for their efforts of ensuring human rights despite COVID19 and devastating floods. They congratulated Pakistan for passing Anti-Torture Bill. They recommended Pakistan for adapting mitigation and adaptation measures to address climate change issues.

The delegates urged Pakistan on shifting more focus towards SDGs; abolishing capital punishment; ensure protection of the rights of minorities women, children and juvenile; sign the international convention on enforced disappearance; strengthen national institutions on human rights; enact domestic violence bill, ensure registration and safety of women voters; and investigates all reports of intimidation and violence against journalists and human rights defenders.

At the end, State Minister Hina Rabbani Khar thanked all the delegates and expressed how much Pakistan has benefitted from the UPR. She listed the policies, laws, mechanisms, and institutions formulated to address the issues raised by the member states.

Having signed and ratified seven of the nine core UN human rights treaties, Pakistan has undertaken a wide range of human rights obligations to its people. The UPR serves as a peer-review mechanism wherein other states provide recommendations to the state under review on how to improve its human rights situation.

The 42nd Session of the UPR Working Group saw Pakistan reviewed for the fourth time on the 30th of January, 2023. Pakistan’s third UPR in 2017 saw it receiving 298 recommendations from various UN Member States, out of which it accepted 168 – a marked improvement from the 2nd cycle when it rejected 7 out of 166 recommendations.

Source: The News

The post Live screening of Pakistan’s UPR session first appeared on Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF).

Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF) alarmed by reports of internet shutdown in Gwadar; welcome reports of restoration

Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF) is alarmed by reports of an internet shutdown in the port city of Gwadar in the Balochistan province amidst clashes between protestors and police. We welcome reports that the internet services have been restored and urge the government to ensure that internet and communication access remains unaffected.

As per Dawn, activists of Haq Do Tehreek and police had clashed after talks between the two for a settlement to end a sit-in were unable to make progress.

According to Dawn, more than a 100 people were arrested and the Balochistan government had imposed Section 144 (power to issue order absolute at once tri urgent cases of nuisance or apprehended danger) of the Criminal Code of Procedures, for a month.

On January 4, Arab News reported that internet services had been restored after 10 days quoting provincial information secretary Hamza Shafqat who said that 3G and 4G services were restored after the city had returned to normalcy and the law and order situation was brought under control.

The government must ensure that access to information and the ability to communicate remains unrestricted. An internet shutdown restricts the public’s vital information and the ability to communicate. It is also a dangerous form of censorship.

Speaking to PPF, Zareef Baloch, an investigative journalism fellow at PPF, said that internet services in the area had been suspended since December 25 due to which journalists were facing issues in sending their news reports to the organizations they work for.

Gwadar Press Club (GPC) President Suleman Hashim said that suspension of internet services was an extreme level of censorship.

“Citizens of the city and the country are being deprived of the information regarding the current situation of the city,” he added.

GPC General Secretary Shareef Ibrahim added that the suspension of cellular networks had cut off the city from other parts of the country and journalists and bloggers can’t report on the actual situation of the area.

Amnesty International South Asia said that the internet shutdown “must be reversed immediately”.“Such disruptions are neither necessary nor proportionate, and inhibits the ability of the people of Gwadar to communicate, access information, seek safety and work,” Amnesty added.

The post Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF) alarmed by reports of internet shutdown in Gwadar; welcome reports of restoration first appeared on Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF).

PPF strongly condemns the attack on Sada e Watan Bureau Chief Naseer Ghumman in Sialkot

Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF) strongly condemns the violent attack on daily Sada e Watan Bureau Chief Naseer Ghumman in Sialkot, Punjab. PPF urges authorities to take immediate steps to ensure the arrest of those behind the attack and to provide the required medical assistance and compensation to the injured journalist.

On December 16,  Ghumman was traveling on a motorcycle with his friend Syed Zahid Ejaz when four unknown gunmen opened fire on him leaving him seriously injured.  Ghumman was under medical supervision at Jinnah Hospital Lahore and his left leg has been amputated due to the deep wound.

Speaking to PPF, Ghumman said that he had raised his voice against the alleged corruption by  Tehsil Municipal Administration (TMA) Sialkot officers after which he was attacked.

“I published news articles in the newspaper revealing the corruption of TMA officers. When TMA inspector Malik Junaid invited me to a fort on December 16, I was on my way there when I was attacked by four unidentified people,” he shared.

A First Information Report (FIR) of the incident was registered in Kotwali Police Station on December 17 under Section 324 and Section 34  of the Pakistan Penal Code.

Investigation Officer Muhammad Naeem told PPF that police was  investigating the matter adding that they were very close to finding the attackers.. With the help of CCTV footage, police have arrested three suspected attackers, he said, adding that further information will be released later.

“According to the initial investigations, Naseer Ghumman  had filed an application for the inquiry against TMA officers in the district commissioner’s office and was writing news stories related to the proceedings as well. The inquiry is in process and one officer has been removed from the job”, Naeem added.

The investigation officer said that the arrested attackers were hired by someone else and the police would identify  the main suspect soon.

Daily Sada-e-Watan Editor Sameer Anwar told PPF that as the bureau chief from Sialkot, Ghumman, had written several news articles on TMA officials. However, he added, it would be premature to comment before the police had finalized their investigation.

“We denounced the vicious assault on Naseer Ghumman and demand the culprits’ quick arrest,” he said.

Syed Zahid Ejaz, Ghumman’s friend and the complainant of FIR told PPF that all four attackers were unknown but they targeted Ghumman specifically, adding that the journalist did not have any personal conflict with anyone.

The post PPF strongly condemns the attack on Sada e Watan Bureau Chief Naseer Ghumman in Sialkot first appeared on Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF).

PPF strongly condemns the attack on Sada e Watan Bureau Chief Naseer Ghumman in Sialkot

Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF) strongly condemns the violent attack on daily Sada e Watan Bureau Chief Naseer Ghumman in Sialkot, Punjab. PPF urges authorities to take immediate steps to ensure the arrest of those behind the attack and to provide the required medical assistance and compensation to the injured journalist.

On December 16,  Ghumman was traveling on a motorcycle with his friend Syed Zahid Ejaz when four unknown gunmen opened fire on him leaving him seriously injured.  Ghumman was under medical supervision at Jinnah Hospital Lahore and his left leg has been amputated due to the deep wound.

Speaking to PPF, Ghumman said that he had raised his voice against the alleged corruption by  Tehsil Municipal Administration (TMA) Sialkot officers after which he was attacked.

“I published news articles in the newspaper revealing the corruption of TMA officers. When TMA inspector Malik Junaid invited me to a fort on December 16, I was on my way there when I was attacked by four unidentified people,” he shared.

A First Information Report (FIR) of the incident was registered in Kotwali Police Station on December 17 under Section 324 and Section 34  of the Pakistan Penal Code.

Investigation Officer Muhammad Naeem told PPF that police was  investigating the matter adding that they were very close to finding the attackers.. With the help of CCTV footage, police have arrested three suspected attackers, he said, adding that further information will be released later.

“According to the initial investigations, Naseer Ghumman  had filed an application for the inquiry against TMA officers in the district commissioner’s office and was writing news stories related to the proceedings as well. The inquiry is in process and one officer has been removed from the job”, Naeem added.

The investigation officer said that the arrested attackers were hired by someone else and the police would identify  the main suspect soon.

Daily Sada-e-Watan Editor Sameer Anwar told PPF that as the bureau chief from Sialkot, Ghumman, had written several news articles on TMA officials. However, he added, it would be premature to comment before the police had finalized their investigation.

“We denounced the vicious assault on Naseer Ghumman and demand the culprits’ quick arrest,” he said.

Syed Zahid Ejaz, Ghumman’s friend and the complainant of FIR told PPF that all four attackers were unknown but they targeted Ghumman specifically, adding that the journalist did not have any personal conflict with anyone.

The post PPF strongly condemns the attack on Sada e Watan Bureau Chief Naseer Ghumman in Sialkot first appeared on Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF).

PPF concerned at the detention of Hayatullah Khan’s brother; calls for an inquiry

Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF) is concerned at the detention Zameer Khan, of on November 19 in the town of Miraali in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province. Khan is a brother of slain journalist Hayatullah Khan who was murdered in 2006.

PPF urges an independent inquiry into Khan’s detention and if it is related to his family’s efforts in courts to get the secret investigation report on Hayatullah’s kidnapping and murder.

According to Ihsan Khan, another brother of Hayatullah, Zameer is in custody of Counter Terrorism Department (CTD) and believes that  he was arrested in retaliation of the letter sent to Interior Ministry asking for the inquiry report of Hayatullah’s murder. Zameer has been suffering from mental illness since 2006 and was arrested by the officials without any reason, Ihsan lamented.

On December 5, 2005, English daily The Nation and Urdu daily Ausaf reporter Hayatullah Khan was kidnapped by five masked men in North Waziristan in the erstwhile Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA). Khan was also a photographer for the European Press. Agency. On June 16, 2006, Khan’s body was found outside a village in Mirali in North Waziristan.

Days after Khan’s body was recovered, on June 20 2006, the Supreme Court had announced the formation of an inquiry commission and presented a report on August 31, 2006. The report of the judicial commission has not yet been released.

On September 1, 2022, Ihsan Khan, another one of Hayatullah’s brothers, wrote a letter to the Ministry of Interior requesting a copy of the report. The Ministry responded to the letter on November 11, 2022 saying that the commission had submitted a report to the apex court and requested them to approach the appropriate forum.

The responding letter quoted Peshawar High Court’s verdict on a writ petition No. 2077/2020 titled Ihsan Khan vs Federation of Pakistan and others on Oct 1, 2022 which was dismissed on the directions of: “The Commission has submitted its report to Honorable Apex Court and this Court cannot direct the Honorable Supreme Court to provide copy of the report to Petitioner”.

“It is obvious that the government has no intention of making the complete findings of the commission of inquiry public,” Ihsan added.

PPF joint demands to release the inquiry report immediately and urge the concerned authorities to conduct an independent inquiry into Zameer’s detention.

The post PPF concerned at the detention of Hayatullah Khan’s brother; calls for an inquiry first appeared on Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF).